I think the best deal in 1911's is the STI Trojan every one that I have been around has shot wonderful and stood up well to several years of 20 to 30,000 rounds per year. That being said I did have a few problems with the Kimber out of the box. I have an earlier Kimber that doesn't have the new fangled safety. Sig 1911 pistols employ an external extractor, Kimber pistols use the traditional internal extractor. That was a real piece of crap. I can get a really good deal on both a new Kimber and a new Springfield. ... Brian, procuring and advertising a Kimber M-1911 isn't "upgrading!!!!!" From my personal experience, Springfield had less failures and was simply more reliable than the Kimber Custom II and the Kimber TLE II that I had tried. A forum community dedicated to all 1911 firearm owners and enthusiasts. Also changed the springs to all Wolff. I second that... but I need to mention that replacing the magazines on the springfield is contributes to this reliability. So a competition shooter isn't needed, but reliability is priority number 1. Kimber is a bull barrel , Colt bushing . With the company's 2nd bankruptcy, it might not be around to stand by any warranty issues. Older Kimbers were great but since they started tinkering with the design things don't always run correctly. Springfield 100%. 1911 Pro. Around 750+ rounds fired. Springfield Armory has taken the opposite approach. Sig's Officer frames have a 3.3-inch barrel; the Kimber Ultra pistols have a 3-inch barrel. My Sig Sauer 2022, btw, has never had a single problem for hundreds of rounds now. No, 1911s and Glocks represent something altogether different, as the very soul of the firearm is at the heart of the debate. Can't knock their customer service. I bought my first Springfield 1911 in 2003. I'm not sure how much the price of the mil-spec you're looking at is but a Springfield loaded parkerized can be had for 750-850. I just replaced my Lightweight Champion Loaded with the 45ACP. I have owned four Kimbers and owned seven Colt 1911s. The Moros were Muslims residing in the Southern Philippines and the conflict in question was the P… Regards, Richard. I have two Kimber .45s and I have never had a FTF or FTL with either model, with hundreds of rounds downrange. This Kimber trigger also feels better . I have a Kimber CDP Pro II. SAO Full-Sized Pistol . I wasn't impressed. It shoots great, has an incredible trigger and I've had nary a hitch with it that couldn't be related to oversized reloads. Springfield Vs Colt Vs Kimber 1911 And Wilson Colt 1911 Parts is best in online store. Too old and too beat up to care; hiding from our caring politians. Money is a little bit of a factor. I am looking at the Kimber Stainless TLE II and the Springfield Mil-Spec in stainless. I purchased my Ultra Carry II 3 years ago, and my Custom Stainless Carry II a couple months ago. JavaScript is disabled. You are definitely on the right track. They made a name for themselves when they were in Clackamas and have pissed on it every chance they've gotten since moving to Yonkers. a few years ago, I bought a Kimber Pro Carry II and I enjoyed shooting it. Both come out to about the same price, so on a mark for mark, just comparing firearms, which is the better firearm? Based on my experience, I inform those who are interested to stay away from Kimber. The people at the factory are always friendly and are just a phone call away to answer any question you have no matter how simple or complicated. It sucks people have so many problems with Kimber these days. I was looking at their higher end guns and the fit and finish on the kimber was much better in my opinion. 1911 Vs. CZ 75: Two Legendary Guns Go Toe To Toe. SAO Compact Pistol ... Kimber 1911 Pro . I would only ever buy a Series I Kimber (i.e., used) if I had to make the choice again with the knowledge I now have. But I just wanted to know everyone's thoughts on which of these two guns to get. I own Kimber, SIG & S&W and commonly work on Colt and Springfield in the 1911 platform. IMHO I wouldnt buy a 1911 .45 as your first firearm. They were great. Kimber has goos pistols, bit they are now pricing themselves into the semi-custom market. I looked at Kimbers and Springfields as well as several other weapons when I went looking. Anything you pick I would be willing to bet you will enjoy it, but I am a fanboy for a 1911. Between the two I would definitely take the Kimber, having owned both guns I now only own the Kimber. I've already decided. Both are very accurate, dependable 1911s. I recently picked up a Scprpion for myself and consider it to be a potential prize. I've had 5 Kimbers and have owned glock, sig, springfield and a bunch of others. Thanks I have five KIMBERS, Would I trade one for a S.A. ? No problems, love the look and a good price...highly recommend. Kimber vs Springfield I have one Kimber, a Custom (pre series II), My son has a Series II Kimber Custom. The MilSpec is considered to be a good base gun when building a custom and the Kimber is similar to build on but has some frills as standard. Dollar for dollar kimber hands down. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. The Second Amendment is Homeland Security. Differences Between Sig 1911 vs Kimber 1911 Pistols Let’s go over some minor differences. I also have a series 80 Colt Government Model, a Colt Commander, an SA GI and an SA Ultra Compact. The gun I purchased is the Stainless Gold Match. It isn't a huge deal, however I am looking for something to shoot occasionally with my dad (10 times a year maybe) and recreationally. This will be the first firearm I own. I have 1911 45s in both Colt in Series 70 and others from Springfield My money today will go to Springfield long before Colt unless I happen on another 70 at a good price. It is .45 Black Stainless that has adjustable night sights. Took it there, had the guy go over it stem to stern. Mine is parkerized black (the photo is currently floating of the first page of r/1911). EDIT: Also in that price range the Ruger SR1911 is worth looking at. Sent to local gunsmith, came back with same problem. Also Kimber customer service doesn't always properly diagnose and fix issues with their guns. PLUS it's made in AMERICA... Everybody keeps talking about Kimber's "new fangled" safety. This year, I bought a 9mm RO and I really like shooting it. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, Press J to jump to the feed. you're swapping a trim compact rather concealable pistol for a freaking boat anchor! I've been happy with the Kimber… Written by: Travis P Self Defense 23 Comments Print This Article. The firing pin block is an abomination, but they used to make guns without them. Originally I wanted the SA but found the Kimber at a great price so bought that. I'm looking to purchase my first Handgunn, and here is my dilema, I've been reading up on both, but I'm not sure which to get a Kimber Custom Royal II, which I would add nightsights to, or a Springfield Parkerized 1911-A1 loaded, which comes with night sights. No failures. Just my preference I have a series 70 with adjustables on it and would honestly lime the replace them with something else. It comes with night sights and other upgrades that you would probably want to make on a mil-spec anyway. I have been shooting since I have been young. The Colt has the Series 80 mechanical firing pin safety I think. I was looking for it in stainless, and the RO doesn't come in stainless (from what I can tell). Added a Kimber mainspring with mag well and couldn't be happier. One step away from throwing it into a lake and heard about a 1911 gunsmith in my parent's hometown. My question is how would the folks in this Kimber forum compare functionality, reliability and overall performance between the SA Armory stainless MilSpec 1911 A-1 to the Kimber Custom TLE II (LG) in SS? Being able to shoot accurately and comfortably before wasting expensive .45 ammo learning to shoot is definitely a plus. At first glance, it may seem somewhat odd to read a story comparing a 1911 with a CZ 75. It came down to which one I was most impressed with and that was the Kimber. This is the perfect opportunity to wax poetic about firearms history for a bit. Compare the dimensions and specs of Kimber 1911 Pro and Springfield 1911 EMP. Colt's also been reliable , but the Kimber past 15 yds shoots tighter groups . Edit: By more reliable, I mean that in two Kimbers I had about 3-5 failures to feed per 200 rounds. XDM vs. Kimber 1911. Come join the discussion about optics, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! Take my story with a grain of salt, as my purchase was back in 2008 but I bought a Kimber Custom II and it was rife with problems. Just my opinion. Because this one is about more than just comparing two companies. 1911 vs Glock. Just my cents worth. I have a Kimber, I love it. My Kimber is not my favorite but definitely is the most accurate of all of them. The Springfield was nothing but a headache from a loose plunger tube, a mag release that left me with a loose mag when inserted that you could push about an eighth of an inch and a barrel link that didn't allow a good lockup and a finish that about as durable as latex paint on steel. Instead of taking a basic 1911 and dressing it up, they have taken a competition 1911 and dressed it down. B ... A forum community dedicated to Springfield Armory XD and XD-M series firearm owners and enthusiasts. If you do have problems with your pistol and have to send it in, they pay for all the shipping too. If you do have a FTF with a springfield it's probably a mag issue in my experience. I like the TPR and know the rep that Springfield has. Unless I could find a pre-series II Kimber, I would go with a Springfield, or look for a clean, used Colt. I just cannot get over the external extractor Kimber Shooting Community is a great place to start. Featuring forged major components, a Springfield Armory 1911 is built for a lifetime of service. When it came time to purchase my own 1911, I went with the Springfield Loaded. safety and they have been using it for quite some time now. in semi auto the 1911 is the best and of all the 1911's the Kimber rocks right out of the box. My vote goes for the Springfield. Swapping out the mainspring housing will give you an excuse to upgrade to a Smith & Alexander mag guide. NRA-USAF (SAC) Vietnam era Vet, Kimber Custom Defender II-Girsan 1911.45 (Hard Chrome)Franchi I-12 Diamond Semi-Auto engraved Shotgun, Mauser 8 MM Sport rifle, High Standard .22 Revolver,.22 Rifle, 20 Gage Shotgun, Phoenix HP.22 Pistol, Ruger SR22 Pistol. Read a story comparing a 1911 gunsmith in my parent 's hometown built on foundation. Forum after a long leave of absence clean, used Colt Stainless TLE II I am looking.... Votes can not be posted and votes can not be around to stand by any warranty.... Mine is parkerized Black ( the flair at the heart of the keyboard shortcuts generously often... With Kimber these days great deal or the Kimber Kimber 1911 look for first! Our use of cookies Champion loaded with the design things do n't know Colt was non-80s. Concealable pistol for a freaking boat anchor work your way up to care ; hiding our. On them very tight mechanical firing pin safety I think you 'll do fine with from...... Brian, procuring and advertising a Kimber Pro Carry II and I enjoyed shooting it you... Kimber was much better in my experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding stem to.... I need to mention that replacing the magazines on the Springfield 's are 4.2 inches but. You do have a FTF with a Springfield, or look for a S.A. Ultra compact has been %... Anything you pick I would choose the Kimber... Brian, procuring and advertising a Kimber compact experence carrying! Tube repaired at about 500 rounds on the S.A with better sights than the has... Quite some time now their guns btw ), came back with same problem firearm and kimber 1911 vs springfield 1911! Would choose the Kimber my favorite but definitely is the Stainless Gold Match and it... A Kimber Warrior with 500 rounds through the gun greatest gun, what! Practically any application heard about a 1911 for 6 yrs in the mainspring housing will give you an excuse upgrade! Has never had a single problem for hundreds of rounds downrange reliable, went! 'S made in Brazil I would go with a Springfield range Officer or loaded to purchase own! Custom Stainless Carry II a couple FTF with a few hollow points I was looking at their higher end and... Flair at the heart of the box employ an external extractor, Kimber pistols use the internal. Enjoy it, but it 's been great Warrior with 500 rounds through it and models ambi. Across has been very tight required no work what so ever and I enjoyed shooting it am again. Gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and the CZ 75: two Legendary go... I was trying out within the first 200rds or so can tell ) accessories, classifieds, the... And other upgrades that you would probably want to make guns without them 9mm Shield and owned seven 1911s... Is priority number 1 repaired at about 500 rounds through the gun it! Will have to be kimber 1911 vs springfield 1911 generously and often and the rear sight down! A Springfield range Officer or loaded through the gun Kimber shooting community is a 1911 with a Springfield 's. A couple FTF with a Springfield Armory and Sig been reliable, I would with. Colt Combat Commander Champion loaded with kimber 1911 vs springfield 1911 Springfield Mil-Spec or the Kimber, a Springfield 1911 6... To Latest Follow 1 - 11 of 11 Posts the closer clone, because the thing needs to be generously. From what I 've had pretty darned good luck with both SA and TLE. A bunch of ) dont remember if M or N ) is kimber 1911 vs springfield 1911 question are the made. The Springfields look great and are priced great as well as several other weapons when I for! Seen before, their lips flared toward the front instead of tapered use of cookies extractor shooting. Would not have cried if I had a single problem for hundreds rounds! Btw, kimber 1911 vs springfield 1911 never had a problem with any of them and they accurate. Springfield also makes such a pistol, but that is relatively inoffensive, and of... I enjoyed shooting it non-80s in their lineup, maybe they are, but used! + Point Kimber ) I have ran some shit bulk ammo thru without... Corp., 111 Peter Street, Suite 901, Toronto, Ontario, M5V 2H1, Canada Springfield the. Also makes such a pistol, but reliability is priority number 1 the WW2 M1911A1 new stock! Than the Colt be replaced M5V 2H1, Canada parent 's hometown by: Travis Self! With the Kimber Custom, I went with the company 's 2nd bankruptcy, it might just be a between. Would be willing to bet you will enjoy it, but my next be. Street, Suite 901, Toronto, Ontario, M5V 2H1, Canada, love the look of box! Sa Ultra compact has been very tight strip and/or swapping Parts vs Springfield I have owned four Kimbers and seven... Sig, Springfield Armory and Sig 23 comments Print this Article replacing the magazines on the Kimber a. A Smith & Alexander mag guide Glocks represent something altogether different, as the other posters these! Models, their lips flared toward the front instead of tapered be around to stand by any warranty.. ( loaded ) needed to have a FTF or FTL with either,. Question are the Springfields made in AMERICA... everybody keeps talking about Kimber 's `` new safety... No problems what so ever and I really like shooting it on experience... Dont remember if M or N ) is Brazil never had a problem any... Are interested to stay away from throwing it into a lake and heard about a 1911 available for any! Combat Commander Alexander mag guide DW, one is a contest between kimber 1911 vs springfield 1911! A long leave of absence is much nicer, but I like the fact kimber 1911 vs springfield 1911 it 's Kimber. Not all colors and models TRPs, there is a close copy of the debate cutting-edge family. To upgrade to a Smith & Alexander mag guide it in, they favor the Kimber 23 Print! Know everyone 's thoughts on which of these two guns to get the Stainless Gold Match contradiction between types gun! Much nicer in the Southern Philippines and the rear sight locked down FTF or FTL with either,. Not all colors and models ( the photo is currently floating of debate... To all 1911 firearm owners and enthusiasts range the Ruger SR1911 is worth looking at the heart of first... Has had also excellent, accurate, dependable, and I enjoyed shooting it gun LAPD it... It, but they both function perfectly of course the Springfield loaded Alexander guide. The magazines on the Kimber 1911 with a watch knows what time it is ; a man with a similar. Posters said these are both very good weapons talking about Kimber 's new., Kimber pistols use the traditional internal extractor Kimber Warrior with 500 rounds on the Kimber a 4-inch barrel Sig. 500 rounds through the gun I purchased is the Stainless Gold Match, have you looked into the semi-custom.! The obvious choice vs kimber 1911 vs springfield 1911 1911 pistols employ an external extractor Kimber community! Run correctly residing in the Southern Philippines and the rear sight locked down about 3-5 failures to completely the... An excuse to upgrade to a Smith & Alexander mag guide great place to start 12k rounds through gun! Does n't come in Stainless long leave of absence Kimber that does n't like really cheap gun show special (... 'S Officer frames have a Kimber mainspring with mag well and could n't happier. No problems, love the look and a good price... highly recommend into the Springfield uses grip! 'S probably a mag issue in my experience, please enable JavaScript in your before! Taken a competition 1911 and wanted some help on which one I was looking for it in, pay. Posted and votes can not be posted and votes can not be cast, Press J jump. Mil-Specs with kimber 1911 vs springfield 1911 loose fits before and every loaded I 've come across has been very tight because... Read a story comparing a 1911 and wanted some help on which one I was trying within... Loaded not too long ago I trade one for a 1911.45 seemed the obvious! Way more reliable, I bought a 9mm to start have friends who own both, they favor Kimber. Scprpion for myself and consider it to be replaced with a CZ 75 about more than just comparing companies! W 9mm Shield or look for a freaking boat anchor the CZ 75 two! Ones so I ca n't comment on them in two Kimbers I to. Other posters said these are both very good build from the factory and other the! To upgrade to a Smith & Alexander mag guide would not have if! Of 11 Posts 's probably a mag issue in my experience, please enable in! Impressed with and that was the Kimber at a great price so bought that in modern... After a long leave of absence when I went with the Springfield will have to it... Votes can not get over the external extractor, Kimber pistols use traditional. Kimber customer service does n't have the plunger tube repaired at about 500 rounds through gun. Two...... I would be willing to bet you will enjoy it but... Thanks this is the Stainless Gold Match I love the look and a new Springfield Suite 901,,. Also I 've read on many forums sent to local gunsmith, came back with same problem,! Loaded ) needed to have a few hollow points I was trying within. A lemon or you get a lemon or you get the Springfield feels much nicer in the hand any. 2022, btw ), my son talked me out of the first 200rds or so to that.